OkCandidate Snags OkCupid''s Approach, Tells You Who To Vote For Come On, Microsoft: Siri Is Making You Look Terrible GrubWithUs Now Wants To Plan YOUR Group Meals (And Do All The Legwork) Battle Of The Browsers: iOS 5''s Browser Is Still (Slightly) Better Than Android''s As webOS Goes Open Source, HP Loses Another Developer Relations Guy NSFW: When Good Search Engine Placement Goes Bad Jawbone Cancels All Pending Up Orders, Refunds Unhappy Owners (Even If They Keep It) YouMail Pulled From The Android Market At T-Mobile''s Request Millions Of People Became Facebook "Developers" Just For Timeline Access With Never Eat Alone, Never Eat Alone Amazon Shares Pop 9.5 Percent Following Surprisingly Good Earnings Watch Twitter''s Flight Conference Live Right Here If Apple Made An Apple Watch Stand, It Would Be The Forté Libratone Unveils Two New Multi-Room Speakers With A Great Design DigitalOcean Adds Floating IPs To Kill Server Downtime Once And For All Molotov Signs Deals With French TV Networks, Launches Beta In November Fashion And Tech Collide Again As Apple''s Jony Ive Will Co-Host Met Gala Apple Updates iWork Apps On All Platforms With Major New Features Passive Fitness Tracking App Human Is Now Much Easier On Your Battery Apple Expands ResearchKit To Autism, Epilepsy And Melanoma Studies Deezer Is Losing Subscribers But Growing Revenue Clustree Grabs $2.9 Million To Match Internal Talent With Job Positions Octoly Is A Multi-Channel Network Alternative For The Rest Of YouTube Zendesk Acquires Business Intelligence Startup BIME Analytics For $45 Million Google starts experimenting with quantum-secure connections in Chrome Google''s Now on Tap gets even smarter Twilio now helps AWS send texts ?Finalmente! Facebook makes it easier to post status updates in multiple languages Trulia can now help you find a place to rent near public transport Google-backed undersea cable between US and Japan goes online tonight AWS''s Elastic File System is now ready for production use Microsoft''s Windows 10 Anniversary Update will arrive August 2nd Google+ turns 5 and is somehow still alive AWS opens its first region in India MongoDB launches Atlas, its new database-as-a-service offering Backblaze launches its low-cost cloud storage service out of beta Microsoft''s open source .NET Core and ASP.NET Core hit 1.0 Video: This is what happens when you talk on your phone at the game Final Fantasy XIV: September 30, 2010 (or 8 days earlier if you buy the collector''s edition!) Europe-only World of Warcraft t-shirts inspire us to greatness Supersonic Green Machine: The future of space flight! People actually paying hundreds of dollars for Transformers: War for Cybertron DLC Formula One to cut emissions by 15 percent within 3 years, becomes first green-ish sports organization Evolution in action: Sound Blaster''s World of Warcraft Tap Chat foot pedal The Cooler Master V6GT CPU cooler has a snazzy LED stripe EFF trying to get Hurt Locker BitTorrent lawsuits thrown out FIFA apologizes for Lampard''s World Cup no-goal, will discuss the introduction of goal-line technology at next meeting Beewi Bluetooth headphones certainly look appealing FIFA responds to requests for goal-line technology: ‘We already said no.’ Microsoft says ‘hardcore gamers’ will be the first to buy Kinect. Um...
Amazon hires Disney SVP Kyle Laughlin as director of Alexa Gadgets
Apple’s battery cases return for the iPhone XS and XR
The Future Of TV Is HTML
This Week On Bullish: Can The Bold Italic Come Back?
Microsoft Drops New Windows 10 Mobile Build, Promises Faster Release Cadence
Cisco Pops 2.5% After Reporting Better-Than-Expected FQ4 Revenue Of $12.84B
Yahoo Sags 4% After Alibaba's Q2 Earnings Disappointment
Microsoft Postpones Ship Date For Its 'Surface Hub' Wall Computer To January
You Can Now Run Windows 10 On Your Mac
Microsoft Drops Another Windows 10 Update
Zulily's Buyout Spike Leaves It Less Valuable Than When It Went Public
Microsoft Launches New Windows 10 Build, Vows To Keep Its Early Access Program Alive

漂流瓶终于彻底拜拜 微信7.0.4新版体验
微信漂流瓶被玩坏了 聊聊漂流瓶里那些事
微信关闭漂流瓶 它曾经满足了我们对世界的好奇
[视频]惠普Chromebook x360 14 G1评测:搭载Chrome OS的商务变形本
借贷宝:停止催收百名裸条女大学生 未满23岁将不得借贷
京东白条多地频现盗刷 消费者遭催收公司“逼债”
借款野蛮催收行为将被规范 真是几家欢喜几家愁
为规范网贷催收 上海互金协会发行业倡议书
腾讯解释为什么微信没有夜间模式 真相你相信吗?

Music Search Engines Tread Fine Legal Line

当前位置: 艾金森 > 门户 > 海外资讯

点击量 10
编辑: 1   作者: Techcrunch   时间: 2018/12/17 15:39:28  

Music search engines are just one of the many ways to get free music on the Internet (BitTorrent and MP3Sparks, formerly AllofMP3, are other popular ways). But for some users they are a near perfect way to listen to music on demand, and/or round out their music collection.

Three that we've been tracking are SeeqPod, Songza and Skreemr.

All three index the web, or parts of the web, looking for music files that people have uploaded to servers. Users search by artist or song. MP3s or other non-DRM sound files with metadata matching the query are served as results.

Unlike sites like LaLa, Imeem and Pandora (and many others), which are all trying to play by various RIAA rules to deliver music to users, music search engines generally don't pay royalties of any kind. The music itself is never on their servers, so they have significantly less copyright exposure. More on that below.

Of the three, Seeqpod is the most useful. It has an index of 8 million individual songs, auto-spell checks queries to find common misspellings, and allows users to create playlists. Seeqpod also has embeddable players, and will try to find music videos of songs you are playing. Seeqpod, by the way, was originally a project of the Lawrence Berkely National Lab.

SeeqPod - Playable Search

Songza also allows users to create playlists and provide embeddable players.Skreemr has bare bones functionality and the hit rate is a little iffy. But they have one feature that the others do not - a direct link to the file on the third party server. That means downloading the song to your hard drive is just a right mouse click away.A fourth company, Deezer, changed its model in the face of litigation in France.

Copyright, Schmopyright

There's no reason to mince words here - the music these sites are playing is almost always copyright infringing. But it's distributed on servers unaffiliated with the search engine itself, making it effectively impossible for the RIAA and its international equivalents to do much about it other than try to force the largest infringers to remove the content. That's because there is little recourse against the search engines themselves.

None of those legalities affect the search engines, though. It's unlikely that under current U.S. law the RIAA can do anything at all to stop them.

Current case law gives a lot of leeway to search engines. I spoke this evening with Andrew Bridges, counsel for Google in Perfect 10 v. Google. In that case, Google was held not held to be infringing the copyright on images just by displaying a thumbnail of the image in search results.

The same arguments are valid with the music search engines, says Bridges (with the caveat that he'd have to look much more closely at the specific facts of any case).

The services may still be liable for contributory infringement, he says, but there just isn't any definitive U.S. case law on matter yet. And no statutes cover contributory infringement.

So for now the search engines are free to link to infringing songs, and even stream them on their site. Just so long as the songs themselves are never stored on their servers. That's good news for Deezer, Seeqpod and Skreemr, and the users who've come to rely on them.

CrunchBase Information